
The dark side of charities
Hoang Nguyen
||
Anti-capitalist ideology
There is an old fable, repeated so often that it has calcified into common sense: give a man a fish, and you feed him for a day; give him the rod, and you feed him for a lifetime. The moral of the story, as silly and obvious as it could be, has been violated several times in the principles of charitable giving. Yet, these violations are much more complex in practice. On these occasions, the fish is fast, renderable, and displayable, while the rod is long-term, and its results are too broad and evenly spread out over time to be measured easily.
What follows in this article is an examination of who the fish actually feeds, starting with the crudest case, where "charity" is simply laundering with better public relations; moving to the far more common case, where giving in the reputation of philanthropy still launders something quieter, our own need to feel good, or someone else's need to be seen as good; and ending with the moment charity starts affecting local economics and politics, leaving with perennial consequences for the receivers.
Bad charities.
First, we will tackle the elephant in the room: Charities established with bad intentions.
Charities and non-profit organizations can be exploited for money laundering by disguising illicit cash as legitimate donations or routing funds through complex networks. After donating, the donor would receive a thank-you and a very general guarantee, such as “this money would be used to help people affected by the thunderstorm,” not where the cash exactly went. In-kind donations are priced by whoever is doing the pricing, letting an organization inflate its "program spending" on paper. When a "charity" declares that the medical supplies it distributed were worth $10 million, who is checking? Additionally, due to the tax-exempt status of charity channels such as the donor-advised fund, this loophole was exploited to evade taxes. Money in these funds would be poured into shell non-profit organizations founded in nations with lower regulations, or used in political engagement. Finally, the thread that holds all of this together is the altruistic “brand name” of charities themselves, when speaking against philanthropy can easily be deemed as selfish. Empirical research proved that the aura of moral goodness coming from within charitable organisations can blind their employees and volunteers, leading to corruption.
The record shows how far this can be pushed. In 2015, the FTC and all 50 states charged four affiliated "cancer charities" — Cancer Fund of America and three others — with siphoning$187 million from donors between 2008 and 2012. Telemarketers promised the money would pay for chemotherapy transport and hospice care; roughly 97 cents of every dollar instead funded six-figure salaries, cruises, and gym memberships for the founder's family. One of the four charities existed for no purpose but raising money for the other three.
In Vietnam, the recent scandals related to celebrities fundraising aren’t trivial either. After the 2020 floods, singer Thủy Tiên raised VND 177 billion directly into her personal account; comedian Hoài Linh collected over 13 billion and still hadn't distributed it a year later, citing COVID travel restrictions. Public pressure eventually forced bank statements out of both. No law had required any of it until the scandal itself produced Decree 93/2021. The money wasn't stolen, but simply sat under one name, accountable to no one, for exactly as long as its holder's reputation could survive the silence.
Even good charities aren’t unconditional
First of all, what's motivating us to donate to a fund?
The fact that most humans love to view themselves as altruists is so unremarkable. We love the moment of reaching into a pocket, dropping something into a box, then savoring the assurance of righteousness. Nevertheless, consider what that feeling actually buys. One example is remedy for blindness, often cited by philosopher Peter Singer. Training a single guide dog in the United States costs somewhere between $40,000 and $50,000. For that same amount, organizations working on trachoma, a bacterial infection and one of the world's leading causes of preventable blindness, can cure or prevent the condition in hundreds of people in the developing world, for as little as $20 to $100 each. Obviously, the latter is much more effective. But many still choose the dog rather than a deeper search for how their charity money will be used most effectively. We aren't donating to the most necessary causes, but the ones that interest us the most.
Then, are we doing good, or are we buying the post-donating aura feeling? This is late-stage capitalism, where benevolence is purchasable through fundraising platforms. This self-assurance effect can divert attention from tackling the root causes of the problem. A tycoon with a million-dollar net worth won’t be concerned about giving away 20$ to a person in the working class. Nevertheless, the money can only sustain the poor man for a couple of days. In the long term, his labor and property continue to be extracted by the exploitative financial system. The real question is whether the tycoon would be willing to forfeit an ample fraction of his wealth for a social reform.
In addition, there are actually multiple explicit and implicit conditions to philanthropic models. Explicit as in conditional aid, which can be manipulative. Explicit as in charities with requirements for recipients, which directly exclude those who aren’t in favor with the philanthropist perspective. Implicit as in non-exclusive charities, where recipients still feel morally obligated to worship the donor as a higher class. Here, we see how gift-giving without voluntary reciprocity undermines the beneficiary's autonomy and further entrenches the social power dynamics among participants.
If a middle-class individual uses charity as a moral exchange, then an elite uses it as a power exchange. We've always seen various foundations initiated by millionaires and celebrities, passionate about solving a cause. Their faces overflow media outlets, with headlines like “Jeff Bezos donates $100 million to U.S. food banks,” portraying them as saints. That may seem generous until we consider his $13 billion daily net worth in 2020. Unsurprisingly, the rich are using their wealth to buy a very intangible but influential asset: public opinion. This drives the narrative away from their exploitative business acts or leads the ignorant majority to condone them. Many billionaire defenders claim that charities are one way to remedy the social cost generated from amassing the wealth. One example is the reputation laundering case of the Sackler family, where millions were poured into art museums across the United States to cover up the family connections to OxyContin, an opioid triggering an epidemic killing over 400000 people.
But is it that simple? Can these donations be perceived as amends for wrongdoings- one cheque, one establishment, and the damage would be eventually patched up? No, of course. If their intentions are good, then their form of rectification should come as tax money. Rather, these charities transfer the responsibility of tackling social issues from the state onto private actors. Yet the causes are frequently selected to build the goodwill and access that political lobbying later spends. More often than not, the views being lobbied for are the ones most protective of private assets. Indeed, wealth brings power, and power brings wealth. All of the above proves that philanthropy is a stepping stone to plutocracy, where society functions according to the interests of the wealthy.
The “side effects” of charities
In this final section, I will address criticisms of aid and charities solely based on its outcome.
First of all, they can harm the local economy. A sudden surge in the supply of a donated good drives down the local manufacturers cannot compete with the flow of free goods and have to cease production. . Self-sufficiency, however, is a cornerstone leading to recovery from crisis. Therefore, superfluous aid can disincentivize production in the long term, stifle the self-recovery process, and create a state of dependency.

Dambisa Moyo, the Zambian economist who wrote Dead Aid, offers the clearest illustration at the smallest scale: a mosquito-net maker in Africa, running a modest factory, producing around 500 nets a week, employing ten people who each support upward of fifteen relatives. What he’s doing was literally development: production, employment, a business embedded in its community. Then a shipment of free nets arrives. It doesn't matter how efficient his factory is, or how badly his region still needs mosquito nets. Free beats efficient every time, and within months the factory closes, the ten jobs disappear, and the region is now more dependent on the next shipment than it was before the first one arrived.
This same logic scales all the way up to the state. Aid, Moyo writes, works "by thwarting accountability mechanisms, encouraging rent-seeking behaviour, siphoning off scarce talent from employment positions and removing pressures to reform inefficient policies and institutions." A government funded by foreign aid doesn't need to tax its own citizens to function and therefore doesn’t feel obliged to reply to their needs. The external supply doesn't just outcompete the local producer, but also removes the pressure that would have forced the local producer, or the local state, to get better.
References
https://fnl.mit.edu/the-problem-with-philanthropy/
https://bluesky-thinking.com/the-dark-side-of-charitable-organisations/
https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2018/06/against-philanthropy/563834/
https://slate.com/culture/2006/10/the-economic-case-against-charity.html
https://www.bbc.co.uk/ethics/charity/against_1.shtml
https://www.thelifeyoucansave.org/blog/peter-singer-on-the-best-ways-to-give-back/
