
Yellowface
Hoang Nguyen
||
Book reviews

R.F.Kuang’s novel is highly addictive. I’ve been in a reading slump lately, and this book has miraculously pulled me out of it. In this novel, we see Kuang play the first-person narrative through June, a white woman. Through the speaking-like prose (literally June voice in the head), the novel satirizes controversial themes like racism, cultural appropriation, plagiarism, and vanity. It also highlights and mocks the hidden dark side of the publishing industry. Not mentioning the fact that this book is such an unconventional and gripping thriller, this already proves how versatile a writer Kuang is.
Never had I thought of the publishing industry as a form of showbiz. But after finishing Yellowface, I’m flabbergasted by how unfair and unethical it can be. For a story to become a bestseller, it has to be unique enough to stand out from the market, yet not so esoteric that it alienates consumers (aka: white readers). In other words, you don’t get to tell the story exactly the way you want, and not every word is allowed to be heartfelt or genuine—otherwise, you’ll rot in obscurity until death. And it’s not only the story that sells, but the author as well. Being a minority with a traumatic backstory, paired with a good face card and polished manners, can take you surprisingly far. This is clearly reflected in many bestsellers that have been heavily criticized as “written to fit the white gaze,” like The Kite Runner.
And in the abyss of despair and anonymity, what do authors do? They STEAL!
Yellowface is about June, a mediocre white author, who steals a novel from Athena, a deceased Asian author, who is also June’s friend. June’s self-justification for her unethical actions is obvious throughout the novel, portraying exactly the stereotype of a white “Karen” – privileged, racist, apathetic, narcissistic. But… the real twist here is: Athena was also a stealer. Athena did not plagiarize directly from a manuscript like June, but she manipulated and triggered people to their breaking point, so they would pour their hearts out into hurtful words. These words would eventually appear in the prose ofAthena’sa next short story or novel. This direct criticism of Kuang to writers prompts me to ask: Is there any entirely original novel? Or are the traumatic materials I have consumed just another form of “stealing” hypocritically masked under the form of “telling the story for the unheard voices”?
If there’s one thing I don’t like about Yellowface, then maybe it’s because of the abrupt and unfitting ending. The penultimate chapters were extremely intense and twisting. We saw how turmoil June was dealing with the anonymous figure “Athena Ghost, or the past consequences of her actions. I almost laughed out loud when it came to the part where June bought incense and chicken to soothe the soul of Athena (this kind of cultural appropriation must be cancelled). However, in the last chapter, when it was revealed that Candace, an old colleague of June, is the ghost, I expected June to kill Candace and become an unsalvageable person. The ending was… Candace escaped and was exposed in June, and she was plotting for the next novel to turn to her side. This ending is just unfulfilling, like the feeling of a rollercoaster being stopped midway.
But anyway, this book is extremely well-plotted and cunningly written. It will provoke you, irritate you, trigger you in all the ways, and you still want to continue messing with it.
PS: tomorrow is my birthday. Happy reading.
