top of page

A cashless dystopia
Part 1: Loss of balance in the payment ecosystem

Hoang Nguyen

||

Innovation...or...subjugation

Introduction

In the anime franchise Doraemon, the twenty-second century is portrayed as a technological utopia. It’s the utopia that we all hope for, somewhere that innovations make life more efficient, somewhere that fulfills our utmost desire to automate and shortcut redundancies. But is this always the case? The similarly technology-dominated world of Cyberpunk: Edgerunners presents a different narrative. In this hypercapitalist world, corporations wield technology to control society. The rich indulge in extravagance while the poor undertake dangerous labor just to barely survive. Back to reality, as cash is being replaced by new payment innovations, a cashless society no longer seems like sci-fi. Nevertheless, the prospect of this future remains the subject of controversy. Will a cashless future resemble Doraemon’s, or will it devolve into a cyberpunk, totalitarian world?

The cashless society is, however, a dystopia. Such a metamorphosis would concentrate monetary power in the hands of entities whose incentives diverge from public welfare and disrupt two fundamental elements of the economy - the payment system and the informal economy. This would trigger a chain reaction that exacerbates instability, exclusion, and inequality and erodes democracy and institutional credibility. That said, there are nations with the institutional and infrastructural capacity to manage the potential risks arising from going cashless.

Cash monopolization

Historically, the macroeconomic value of cash has extended past the conventional functions of money. Cash is the only form of central bank money directly accessible to the public, helping ensure stability and interoperability within the financial system. Nowadays, money issued by private entities like bank deposits or money market funds dominates daily transactions worldwide. Yet its credibility relies on its convertibility into cash and on legal backstops, such as deposit insurance and banking regulations.

Should cash be abolished, this complementary relationship will be disrupted, nudging consumers towards private payment ecosystems. Technological advancements hasten this transformation by introducing innovations that address the drawbacks of previous products. However, this development also elicited concerns among governments. Meta’s proposed stablecoin, Libra, intended for daily transactions, immediately faced strong backlash from regulators and central banks (CBs) worldwide upon its announcement. Why is that the case?

First, this reliance on private networks threatens monetary sovereignty. The state achieves monetary sovereignty if it can control its unit of account. Effective monetary policy depends on most economic activity being denominated in a common unit. However, the emergence of multiple private digital currencies can fragment the monetary system into competing units of account. Furthermore, digital payment infrastructures significantly reduce the cost of cross-border transactions. This convenience can motivate domestic residents to substitute unstable domestic currencies for dominant foreign currencies such as the USD or CNY. Moreover, a fully cashless society eliminates the only direct and accessible legal tender to the public. Overall, digitalization accelerates the migration of monetary power from public institutions toward financial technological corporations.

Private financial systems, however, are inherently fragile. Bank deposits are redeemable on demand despite being backed by relatively illiquid assets such as loans. Similarly, stablecoins often promise immediate redemption at a fixed value, exposing issuers to redemption pressure when the liquidity or quality of reserve assets is called into question. As confidence deteriorates, both deposits and stablecoins become vulnerable to runs. Yet, public money stabilizes this ecosystem amid panic by issuing cash, a safe redemption anchor. This is best exemplified by comparing the U.S. before and after the National Banking Act. Competing private banknotes plagued the system with instability as confidence fluctuated with issuers’ reserves and collateral during the Free Banking era, whereas the subsequent introduction of nationally backed currency corrected this by linking private issuance more closely to public authority.

Furthermore, these private actors’ incentives diverge from public welfare. Private issuers benefit from expanding their payment networks globally, but they are exempt from the full social costs of financial crises. Should their importance within financial systems increase, they may acquire “too-big-to-fail” status. Governments are then obligated to rescue them during crises despite lacking full regulatory control, thereby creating a moral hazard.

Deprivatized digital money and its concerns

To offset money privatization, governments and CBs have begun developing Central Bank Digital Currencies (CBDCs) as a form of public digital money. Compared with private digital money, CBDCs can improve financial inclusion, reduce transaction costs, and restore part of the public sector’s influence over monetary systems. Nevertheless, this advantage can draw customers away from the private banking sector, weakening the traditional role of commercial banks.

First, as households transfer part of their savings into CBDCs, commercial banks will lose access to cheap funding from retail deposits, one of their most stable and least expensive sources of funding for lending. Attempts to counteract the effect through wholesale funding markets or long-term deposits are clearly more expensive than retail deposits. Hence, a reduction in credit availability and a spike in lending rates would likely happen following the introduction of CBDCs. More critically, the safety of CBDCs leads to their role as “flight-to-safety” assets during periods of instability. Like cash, CBDCs are direct liabilities of the central bank and are generally perceived as safer than bank deposits. Unlike cash bank runs, nevertheless, digital bank runs occur instantaneously in the absence of logistical friction. This accelerates liquidity outflows from commercial banks, weakens confidence in the banking system, and amplifies systemic instability.

Overall, concerns from the government and the private sector focus on a loss of balance in the payment ecosystem, leading to a dilemma that fosters financial vulnerability and payment market centralization. In contrast, public apprehension focuses on the erosion of democracy and autonomy, as well as the exclusion of vulnerable groups from economic participation.

The programmability of CBDCs enables authorities to impose conditions on how, where, and when money is spent: governments can impose expiration dates, geographic restrictions, or purpose-bound spending rules to stimulate or restrain consumption. More threateningly, a traceable system is a potential weapon for the government to use to punish political dissidents. Authorities could freeze protesters’ accounts or restrict transfers to a politically unfavorable organization. The freezing of bank accounts during the 2022 Canadian trucker protests is an example of the weaponization of digital payment systems. These measures harm consumer autonomy and politicize money from a neutral medium of exchange into a tool to dictate society.

The politicization of CBDCs can even threaten the CB’s independence. Despite being labeled as a monetary tool, CBDCs also support certain fiscal functions, such as subsidies and transfer payments. These aspects are vulnerable to political exploitation: the government can pressure the CB to finance government spending or pursue electoral objectives. This risks weakening inflation controls and eroding confidence in the CB’s credibility over time, leading to a deterioration in monetary sovereignty, undermining the problems CBDCs were intended to solve.

Overall, concerns from the government and the private sector focus on a loss of balance in the payment ecosystem, leading to a dilemma that fosters financial vulnerability and payment market centralization. In contrast, public apprehension focuses on the erosion of democracy and autonomy, as well as the exclusion of vulnerable groups from economic participation, which would be explore further in part 2. 

Suggested reading

Vintage as Authenticity: The Thrift Store Economy & Retro-Commodification

Art Auctions: Money Laundering or Deeper Value?

PUNKonomics!

The Newsletter

Explore

How value actually works  in the punk underground, the economy, and the fiction that explains both.

Follow Us

  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • X

© 2026 PUNKonomics! — written by Ayden Nguyen

bottom of page