top of page

A comparison between “Animal Farm” and “Lord of the Flies”

Hoang Nguyen

||

Innovation...or...subjugation

Introduction

What is society? By definition, society is a group of individuals engaged in social interaction on a regular basis, or a large social group sharing a common territorial space or community. Is it that simple? If the definition of society were simply identical human automatons interacting with daily frequency, then riots or conflicts would never occur. At the same time, the “graph” depicting the peaks and declines of society would be nothing but a straight horizontal line. However, history has proven that no society can remain completely stable for an infinite time, simply because society is a complex structure, composed of innumerable different factors that even science cannot fully explain. The two novels, Animal Farm by George Orwell and Lord of the Flies by William Golding, simulate a simpler version of society. At the same time, each novel constructs a picture of a society built and collapsing from two different, yet not entirely opposing, perspectives. Both novels are monumental works of world literature, evoking lessons that are both profound and satirical about social contexts in general and human nature in particular.

Animal Farm by George Orwell was published in 1945, in the context of a world that had just gone through World War II, and the Soviet Union was rising as a great power. Orwell, with direct experience of war and disappointment at Stalin’s totalitarian regime, borrowed the form of a fable to criticize the corruption of revolution and the danger of dictatorship arising from the ideal of equality. Meanwhile, Lord of the Flies by William Golding was published in 1954, when the reverberations of World War II, the fear of nuclear war, and the collapse of human morality still haunted the West. As a former naval officer, Golding witnessed human brutality and wrote the novel as proof that civilization is only a thin veneer, which can disintegrate at any time to make way for savage instinct. Both works, though different in their birth circumstances, reflect a shared pessimism of the twentieth century: the fragility of social order and the lurking darkness in human nature.


Opposing influential forces

In Animal Farm, after enduring oppression, the animals staged a great strike to escape human domination. Snowball, the most intelligent pig on the farm, built an empire of egalitarian socialism. The ideology of “Animalism” was built on seven commandments, centered on the notion that the common enemy is man, and that there is equality for all animals. Thanks to his slick tongue, he built a spirit of labor in the other animals. From forced labor and starvation, the animals came to enjoy a prosperous life through their own work. Snowball also came up with many novel initiatives to serve farm life. He taught the alphabet, created an electricity-generating windmill, and organized democratic delegate meetings. Thus, Snowball is the symbol of revolution and the industrialization of socialism.Napoleon is a pig more taciturn and cunning. Under Snowball’s rule, he disagreed with many viewpoints. Napoleon believed the windmill was unnecessary because only a full belly mattered. And to confront humans, he thought the farm should be filled with weapons, rather than calling on other farms to rise up together. Through the arguments between the two pigs, the author cleverly constructed Napoleon’s selfish nature.


When Napoleon overthrew and expelled Snowball, he revealed his manipulative and dictatorial nature. He abolished the weekly meetings. He reversed course and ordered the windmill built for commercial purposes. Through the pig Squealer, he spread false information about Snowball: “Snowball destroyed the windmill,” “Snowball was Jones’s spy, the farm’s owner.” Gradually, Napoleon became a wise pig in the public eye: “Napoleon is always right.” The products made by the animals were no longer used for consumption but became goods traded with humans. The commandments were altered so the pigs could run amok at will. Animals who opposed were executed. The foolish animals kept believing in Napoleon’s rule without realizing they were circling back into the vicious cycle of exploitation. Thus, Napoleon is the embodiment of totalitarianism and social inequality.


If Animal Farm raises the contrast between socialism and totalitarianism, the polarized picture in Lord of the Flies shows the opposition between order and riot.

Lord of the Flies tells of a group of children trapped on a deserted island. In such a situation, the first human instinct is to find a way to be rescued. When the children elected Ralph as leader, they were gradually modeling a democratic society. Ralph divided labor evenly—tending the fire, hunting, and building shelters. As in the society of Animal Farm, the children in Lord of the Flies also held meetings to contribute ideas. If Ralph symbolizes democratic order, then Piggy, whom Ralph always turns to for counsel, is the embodiment of reason and knowledge. Piggy, with his glasses, not only brings the light of civilization through fire but also symbolizes the voice of science and lucidity in a community sliding toward chaos.

Within that ordered world, there is always a force ambitious for power. Jack is the leader of the hunters, passionate about killing and power. In Jack’s world, the children desire to hunt the island’s “beast” chaotically and are willing to kill dissenters. They do not care about being rescued; they only want to satiate the craving for meat. Yet to say Jack symbolizes riot is not enough. The force always lurking to overthrow order is more precisely the savage instinct and the desire to rule inherent in each human being. In Ralph’s world, hunting is to sustain ordered society. Under Jack’s rule, hunting is how people gratify the passion for killing and dominating weaker creatures. Golding is also very deft in using the figure of boys. Males are stereotyped by society as the “strong sex” and possess a nature that craves conquest. The children seem innocent, but that very innocence is nearer and more intact, in order to expose the primal instinct: the hidden desire to conquer and to shed blood.


Different emblems of power.

In Animal Farm, pigs are the species that dominate the farm. Other animals are somewhat less intelligent; some cannot even learn past two letters of the alphabet. The pigs used their intelligence to establish invisible rule over the others. Why pigs? In life, pigs are often associated with laziness but cunning. Orwell uses pigs as a metaphor for a deceitful ruling class that deems itself wise in order to govern and profit from the labor of the lower classes. The image of pigs also satirizes revolutionary leaders who degenerate into dictators blinded by the ambition of power.

The image of the windmill in the story is precisely the tool by which the powerful exercise control, and it also symbolizes revolution. However, its purpose contrasts sharply under two different regimes. Under Snowball’s socialism, the windmill promised to generate electricity, helping the animals work only three days a week. In contrast, under Napoleon’s totalitarianism, the animals had to labor without rest to build the windmill. Napoleon’s propaganda turned the windmill into a symbol of deceit: a structure erected to free labor became shackles. After years of manipulation, the animals forgot the windmill’s original purpose. When completed, Napoleon used it to mill corn for trade with humans, rather than generate electricity. In the end, what Snowball once called “the light of civilization” is corrupted, as revolution, from the dream of equality, becomes a tool serving dictatorship.

In Lord of the Flies, the author plants two opposing symbols of power. The conch shell that Ralph finds on the beach is used to summon the children. In the world of order, whoever holds the conch may speak—an allegory for freedom of speech in a democratic society. Unlike the herd of pigs, the conch does not build a total domination but distributes power evenly to individuals with the compromise of cooperation to build society. When Jack lured the children to follow him, the conch gradually lost its unifying force. At that point, power gradually shifted to Piggy’s glasses.


The glasses in the story bring fire, as the originating symbol of two civilizations. Like the windmill, under two different regimes, Piggy’s glasses also symbolize contrasting values. Ralph uses fire to signal ships, to reinforce order in society. In contrast, Jack regards the glasses and the fire as tools of domination. Jack uses fire to burn the forest, to hunt down and exterminate dissenters. This also explains why Jack steals Piggy’s glasses rather than the conch: in riot, the unifying force of democracy becomes meaningless, and fear will rule more easily. The moment the conch shatters under a boulder is precisely the moment when law, democracy, and reason collapse on the island. In the near-final scenes, flames engulf the forest, like savagery and debauchery gradually swallowing human reason.


Transition between two opposing forces

Before analyzing the transformation between the two forces, we must assess a third force, a hidden influence that makes both sides in the stories tremble.

In Lord of the Flies, the children always mistakenly feel that a monster is present on the island. In fact, the “beast” is only the shadow of a dead pilot’s body in a tree. The tragedy peaks when Simon, the only one who realizes the truth, is mistaken for the “beast” in the frenzy of ritual and beaten to death by the group. Through this, Golding points out: what humans fear is not some external supernatural force, but the darkness lying within their wild instinct. In the structure of society, when individual fears resonate, they crystallize into a superstitious belief that governs collective behavior. When there is order, superstition is only the submerged part. Under Ralph’s leadership, the children at first still held a common goal and did not overly sink into chasing the “beast.” Yet when they discovered the pilot’s body stuck in the treetop and mistook it for the beast, Jack exploited that fear to split from the group and form his own tribe with the aim of killing. Sadly, many children quickly forgot the initial ideals of maintaining the rescue fire and building order, and they abandoned Ralph to follow Jack. They let fear merge with violent instinct, turning the hunt into a savage ritual and losing their very innocence. Through this simulated society, Golding warns that civilization is a fragile shell, and when it vanishes, humans transform themselves into the very “monster” they have always feared.


In Animal Farm, this hidden force is mankind. Humans symbolize domination. In the early years of the animal kingdom, Snowball established the seven commandments, reminding the animals of a common enemy and teaching them how to treat their fellows. This is precisely the presence of religion and belief in the social context. Unlike the image of the beast spreading fear in Lord of the Flies, these commandments helped reinforce trust among the animals and protect them from external forces. From that, we can affirm that religion is the boundary preventing humans from plunging into primal frenzy.

However, religion is also a tool for the totalitarian ruling class to manipulate the ruled. When Napoleon seized power, he continuously offered false justifications for his actions. The animals wondered: “Does this agree with the seven commandments?” Every time they returned to read the commandments at the farm gate, they had been changed. But with dim minds and blind obedience, the herd had no idea. They were not whipped into riot like the children, but instead they drowned themselves in forced labor and illusions of a beautiful society. Religion can be the light that frees humans from degradation, but it can also become the blindness that robs humans of reason.


So what caused socialism in the Animal Kingdom to collapse? As in Lord of the Flies, it is when the antagonist force seizes power, only in a more direct way. In other words, Napoleon is the representative of a “human” in the farm. After many years, the pigs begin walking on two legs and rule the others like slaves. The core of Animalism—“Four legs good, two legs bad”—is turned into “Four legs good, two legs better.” The final scene is laden with allegory: “Looking from pig to man, and from man to pig, it was impossible to say which was which.” In Lord of the Flies, from chaos to civilization and then back to chaos. In Animal Farm, from slavery to equality and then back to slavery. The world in both stories is like a vicious circle erected by human nature, imprisoning itself, never able to escape.

Suggested reading

Vintage as Authenticity: The Thrift Store Economy & Retro-Commodification

Art Auctions: Money Laundering or Deeper Value?

PUNKonomics!

The Newsletter

Explore

How value actually works  in the punk underground, the economy, and the fiction that explains both.

Follow Us

  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • X

© 2026 PUNKonomics! — written by Ayden Nguyen

bottom of page